Real data, ranked. No fluff, no filler.

To every veteran and everyone serving today: thank you for your service.

← The 10 Best Claw Hammers

JORGENSEN 20 oz Rip Claw vs Mr. Pen 8 oz Magnetic

Our Best Overall vs our Best Budget claw hammers — is the upgrade worth it?

The short answer

The JORGENSEN 20 oz Rip Claw costs $17 more (243% more) than the Mr. Pen 8 oz Magnetic — $23.99 vs $6.99. For the extra money you get: an anti-vibration grip, one-piece forged construction, and side-puller jaws.

Buyers rate them 4.7 vs 4.8 stars, and the JORGENSEN 20 oz Rip Claw has fewer reviews behind its rating (498 vs 10,146). On our 100-point scale that works out to 97 vs 84.

Bottom line: if you'll use it often, the JORGENSEN 20 oz Rip Claw is worth the $17. For occasional jobs around the house, the Mr. Pen 8 oz Magnetic does the work for less.

Price no object? Our pick is the ESTWING E3-16C ($31.79) — see why on the full ranking.

Side by side

JORGENSEN 20 oz Rip Claw
Best Overall		Mr. Pen 8 oz Magnetic
Best Budget
Price$23.99$6.99
Rating 4.7 4.8
Reviews49810,146
Our score97/100 (#1)84/100 (#6)
Bought on Amazon300+/mo5K+/mo
Head weight20 oz8 oz
HandleSteel (one-piece)Fiberglass
ClawRip (straight)Curved
FaceMilledSmooth
Length——
Anti vibeYesNo
MagneticYesYes
One pieceYesNo
Side pullerYesNo

Prices, ratings and review counts captured from Amazon on 2026-11-10; prices change often.

Best Overall
JORGENSEN 20 oz One-Piece Forged Rip Claw Hammer with Magnetic Nail Holder
JORGENSEN

JORGENSEN 20 oz One-Piece Forged Rip Claw Hammer with Magnetic Nail Holder

The most feature-loaded hammer on the list for the money. One-piece forged steel, a magnetic nail starter, a shock-absorbing anti-slip grip, and a side nail puller notch — everything the pricier framing hammers have, at a mid-list price.

Choose it for

  • One-piece forged construction — head can't come loose
  • Magnetic nail starter plus a side puller for stubborn nails
  • Shock-absorbing, anti-slip grip
  • Strong value for a fully featured 20 oz

Watch out for

  • Milled face marks finish surfaces
  • 20 oz is heavier than most need for general work
  • Newer brand with fewer reviews than the legacy names
Check today's price →
Best Budget
Mr. Pen 8 oz Magnetic Claw Hammer, Small Nail Hammer
Mr. Pen

Mr. Pen 8 oz Magnetic Claw Hammer, Small Nail Hammer

The best small hammer, and the best-seller of the bunch by review count. At 8 oz it's built for hanging pictures, tacking trim, and drawer-kit jobs — not framing. The magnetic head starts small nails and brads so you don't hit your fingers.

Choose it for

  • Magnetic head starts small nails one-handed
  • Light 8 oz is easy to control for delicate work
  • The cheapest pick on the list
  • Amazon best-seller with over 10,000 ratings

Watch out for

  • 8 oz is too light for framing or heavy nailing
  • Not a full-size general-purpose hammer
  • Small claw pulls only small nails
Check today's price →

Quick answers

Is the JORGENSEN 20 oz Rip Claw worth the extra money over the Mr. Pen 8 oz Magnetic?

The JORGENSEN 20 oz Rip Claw costs $17 more (243% more) than the Mr. Pen 8 oz Magnetic — $23.99 vs $6.99. For the extra money you get: an anti-vibration grip, one-piece forged construction, and side-puller jaws. Bottom line: if you'll use it often, the JORGENSEN 20 oz Rip Claw is worth the $17. For occasional jobs around the house, the Mr. Pen 8 oz Magnetic does the work for less.

Which has better reviews, the JORGENSEN 20 oz Rip Claw or the Mr. Pen 8 oz Magnetic?

The JORGENSEN 20 oz Rip Claw is rated 4.7 stars from 498 reviews; the Mr. Pen 8 oz Magnetic is rated 4.8 stars from 10,146 reviews.

What is the best claw hammers pick overall?

Our Best Overall is the JORGENSEN 20 oz Rip Claw (score 97/100), ranked against 9 other claw hammers on rating, review volume and features.

See the full top 10

These two are picked from a ranking of 10 claw hammers, scored on star rating, review volume and the features that matter for the job. See all 10 and the one to avoid →

More head-to-heads